Monday, January 30, 2012

Final Essay One: Evaluating Sources


Taylor Reed
Professor Ishai Barnoy
English 111
28 January 2012
Essay One: Evaluating Sources
           
            Have you ever heard of that one overly used phrase a young child direct towards their parent: “Mom, where do babies come from”? That child has only two sole purposes for asking that specific question. For one, they truly have no clue where they came from and secondly, they have no other means to finding out their own answer. No matter where information derives from, it always has hidden factors deep within. For instance, whether it’s reliable or completely useless, or if it possess intentions much more significant than what it is relaying to the desired audience. Needless to say, the origin of informational sources has a substantial amount of influence on the recipients who put it to use.
            As a little girl, like most children at that age, I asked a lot of questions daily, some more sensible than others. Because of my inability to gather reliable facts on my own, I constantly would run to my mom and with much hope of her knowing the correct answer to all of my little inquiries. As I grew older, through education and a few years of wisdom, I was more capable of finding out whatever I needed to know simply through my own means of researching. Now I would go to my mother less often when I needed an answer to the things I didn’t know. From that point on I had resources that I could use freely and independently to educate myself on the most simple to the most complex questions I had. These techniques were also used in slightly less critical ways when communicating between friends. If I was told something about one person, I could either take that and run with it or I could dig a little deeper by using personal discussions. Even though there was a greater chance of a statement being unreliable, at least I had learned how to find out for myself whether it was true or false. There are so many differences in the techniques of information gathering from when I was younger to as I became older. But the main difference was that I relied on whatever my mom told me as a child and to me, whether fiction or fact, I believed it simply because there was no way for me to disprove it. Once becoming of age where you can go out and research whatever you please, you tend to have never-ending questions at some point. That’s probably the biggest effect that availability of resources has on me now: I spend more time seeking information that hasn’t already been given to me since there are so many places to gather them from.
            Before the internet was even thought about, a good percentage of people usually had their nose stuck in the daily newspaper somewhere in a barber shop or downtown café. Then once they came home from work, they’d gather around the “tube” or radio and closely listen to their favorite news station to get in on recent occurrences. After that, came more sources of information like online news articles, web pages, search engines like Wikipedia, and the list continues. With these different sources also come factors like the amount of reliability each one holds. Because we have so many more ways to express opinions and facts or both, it is potentially up to the individual to determine whether or not what they see, read or hear is dependable. Typically, a newspaper article is going to contain a recent incident or argument containing only facts, with its main purpose being to supply the reader with useful information. This holds true for various other sources as well. On the other hand, there are those articles, whether in a magazine or on a web page, that sometimes contain more opinion than fact. They’ll express a specific matter, and rightfully, the author will give their take on that subject. Then, there are going to be sources that you come across that’ll contain the best of both worlds, presenting facts and opinions, sometimes implied and other times plainly stated. Different sources vary in style depending on the author’s view on the information they’re relaying and the audience they intend on appealing to. Sometimes the author doesn’t have a specific stand on a topic and that’s when you see mainly facts, statements and quotes. Then there are times when the author feels strongly about what they’re relaying, thus giving an even stronger and clearly stated opinion. In complete sense, no source is right or wrong, and all approaches can be useful to a writer depending on their subject. Essentially, a source can be as useful as you allow it to be, and there are no limits to where an individual gathers insight from. However, there are a few key points one should keep in mind when picking sources for a paper. Like for instance, if they are to be writing a non-bias research paper about teen pregnancy, an online article that’s pro-choice wouldn’t be a very clever source to use. It’s always important to understand the main subject you want your paper to portray and use sources that are helpful and supportive, and don’t switch up the main idea. Sources that contain more opinion than facts are typically not very helpful when a writer is trying to steer away from partial ideas. But, if you use sources that contain both sides of the argument, and know how to intertwine them carefully into the paper, then it could be helpful for the reader to receive two separate ideas in one. As a final point, understanding the source you’ve chosen is just as imperative as the subject that it will eventually support.
            When pondering about my topic for my upcoming research paper, I already had a pretty good idea of what type of sources I wanted to use to complete my ideas. In my personal opinion, I don’t feel as though either one would be more useful than the other. They would both play their part in supporting my main ideas that I wanted to express. One, coming from a daily newspaper, and the other, from an online article, seem to have enough informative facts that are needed to give my paper more sustenance. Both are non-bias and display only explanations of a recent situation and the result of that incident. Even though I will have a strong opinion being stated, these sources didn’t have to support my opinion in order to be useful. I don’t believe that either source had an intended audience besides whoever was interested in the matter of police brutality. The group responsible for the newspaper article was the Associated Press of California and the author of the online article was a man named Henry K. Lee. Lee is a cops and courts reporter for the San Francisco Chronicle who has written many articles, not to mention a book, on high-profiled cases and social matters. Conclusively, both were quite general, using only a few detailed instances on events the author was reporting on.
            For my first source, the newspaper article, the AP of California reported on an incident that occurred in Oakland, California which involved hundreds of Occupy protesters and the local Oakland police. When demonstrators used physical violence against the authorities and failed to comply with orders to leave, the police then used tear gas to resolve the matter. “Police said that three officers were injured and that 19 people were arrested” (“Police Use Tear Gas” A3). Resulting from this situation, the same protestors then stated that instead, they will be using a nearby vacant building and use it as a social center. Even though it isn’t long or says a whole lot, this source is useful in the sense that it provides me with an example of a more general matter that I want to go in depth within my essay. It also doesn’t show any bias towards the main idea and allows me to elaborate around the topic in my own way, which is another reason why I decided it could be helpful. For my second source, the online article, Lee described an event that happened at the University of California in Berkeley. This case was a matter of pointing fingers, and resulted in innocent protestors being assaulted by the campus police, which led to a lawsuit being filed.  “The suit, filed in U.S. District Court in San Francisco, said law enforcement officers, under the direction of UC Berkeley Chancellor Robert Birgeneau, needlessly used their batons to jab nonviolent protesters outside Sproul Hall on Nov. 9. The officers and deputies "conducted a planned, coordinated and violent attack against these peaceful protesters" by using "shocking, unconscionable and excessive force," states the lawsuit, which seeks unspecified damages” (Lee 1). When I came across this source, also non-bias, I believed it to be very useful because it gave me yet another good example to go in deep discussion about and would let me really express my personal opinion. It portrayed innocent people who came in contact with violent and unnecessary forces used against them for no reason whatsoever, which is something I’m utterly disturbed by. Although neither source agreed nor disagreed with my belief, they’re helpful simply because they both gave me vivid instances that will make me want to express my point to my intended audience, young people who may feel the same way I do about police brutality.
            I will eventually use both articles to give my readers examples of my greater subject, needless violence on innocent people from police. I will probably use the first source to show one reason why authorities act in the particular ways they do, but also to display an example of when it is necessary, as oppose to when it isn’t. The second source will allow me to follow up with the first one. It’ll show an instance where people are stripped of their rights and innocence by the very people who are supposed to protect them. Essentially, both sources will positively coincide with the other to make my point more binding. In addition to the sources I already have, I want to use a source that agrees with my view. Perhaps a magazine article or video interview will help me to do so. I feel as though it’ll enhance my paper even more and give my audience more reason to understand why I feel so strong like I do. Where I find my next source is important if I am going to correctly convey and validate my attitude against police violence.



Works Cited Page

Associated Press. "Police Use Tear Gas Against Protesters." The Washington Post [Oakland,
     California] 29 Jan. 2012: A3. Print.

Lee, Henry K. "Cal Students Sue Over Police Tactics At Camp." San Francisco Chronicle 30 Nov. 2011:
 C3. Opposing Viewpoints Resource Center. Web. 29 Jan. 2012. 

           
           




3 comments:

  1. Hey Taylor, overall I think your essay is really good it has a great flow and many examples. I didn't see any error in it and the introduction has a great pull. Enjoyed the reading.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey I got your tweet so here i am. I liked your essay. It's funny how you and I used to go to our parents (you to your mom and me to my dad) for all the answers of the world. Only thing i'd double check is the part in the 4th paragraph where you say : the author of the online article was a man named henry k. lee [who] is a cops and courts reporter...
    Otherwise great job and this is meant as constructive criticism ;)

    ReplyDelete