Taylor-Sy’mone Reed
English Composition 111
Ishai Barnoy
2/16/12
Essay
Two: Arguing Without Prescribing
In today’s culture, there are so many diverse and
controversial aspects that are worth conversing or even arguing about. Of
course there’s always the part where strongly stated opinions come in and can
ultimately shift the nature of the conversation. Either way, there are some
people out there who stop and ask themselves one important question: “Is what I’m
saying really worth talking about?”
Or in a more simply stated way: “Does the issue I feel so passionate about even
have any significance behind it?” If one can identify and clearly answer those
questions, there will usually be another one that follows directly after: “If
it does matter, then what is it
exactly?” Well that’s what I’m trying to come to terms with myself. What is it that
makes me feel compelled to argue my stand and how can I better explain that to
someone who isn’t aware of what it is. Also, does the subject I’m about to
introduce even exist as a problem?
The police, in the simplest way, can be defined as “an
organized civil force for maintaining order, preventing and detecting crime,
and enforcing the law” (Dictionary.com). Their job is also to ensure the
well-being of all civilians and protect them from those who decide to be
defiant against the established laws of the country. Their existence, although
in many forms, can be traced all the way back to pre-civilized villages and
communities in different parts of the world. They are considered part of a higher
elite group of people who have authority over the general public, as instructed
by the government. At all times, they are required to follow strict procedures
and protocol to guarantee an equally secure environment. Sounds good right? Ok
now let’s pair that up with another word and see what type of effect it has.
Brutality is the “state or quality of being ruthless, cruel, harsh, and
unrelenting” (The Free Dictionary by Farlex).
Hence, police brutality is excessive force of physical harm, verbal
attacks or even psychological intimidation all at the hands of a police
officer. Examples of this brutality are false arrests, racial profiling and
discrimination, sexual abuse and humiliation, prejudice against different
groups of individuals, and ultimately unnecessary physical coercion against
people who pose no threat or harm to others in their environment.
Police
brutality dates back hundreds of years ago, ever since police forces were put
to play and ever since they have sort of become a part of society as a whole.
For example, during the civil rights era, the amount of cruelty against
innocent people was mind-blowing. Protestors against racial discrimination would
get sprayed painfully by fire hoses, beaten with batons, and wrongfully
arrested. Another example would include, “…the Pennsylvania state militia, not
members of the local police force, killed twenty during the 1877 Pittsburgh
railroad strike; between 1869 and 1892, private Pinkerton officers were
involved in brutally breaking seventy-seven strikers” (Answers.com). To their
understanding, providing this amount of force was necessary in order to
undermine labor actions and control the leisure of the working class.
In one incident, the murder of Sean Bell was a prime example of inappropriate force used on an innocent man. It occurred on November 25 of 2006 in Jamaica Queens, New York when Sean Bell and a few friends were leaving his bachelor party at a nearby strip club downtown. Five undercover officers then appeared at the location and let off 50 bullets, mortally wounding Bell and severely injuring his friends inside of their car. One may wonder what caused these officers to commit such a “crime”. Well they claimed they believed Bell and his associates were up to no good after a confrontation inside the club made the officers believe the group of men was armed and dangerous. Sadly, an eager and soon-to-be married Nicole Paultre-Bell was left in disarray during one of the most important events of her life, her wedding day. Let’s look at another occurrence to get a better feel of how some police forces decide to “secure the safety of the public”. One of the most popular cases was one that involved Rodney King in 1991 Los Angeles, California. “In 1991, a videotape circulated around the world of Rodney King being beaten by L.A.P.D. officers after they put an end to the 8-mile high speed chase. Once surrounded, King and his two friends were ordered to step out of the vehicle and lie face down on the ground. King refused to comply, but eventually got out of the car and resisted an arrest. Once King got physical with some of the officers, they shot him with a Taser gun to knock him to the ground. He was then beaten multiple times with a baton and kicked repeatedly.” (Criminal Justice Degrees Guide). This incident became a viral media sensation and developed into one of the most appalling police brutality incidents in history. When coupling the two words “police” and “brutality” together, it creates a greatly reversed negative connotation. While “police” is supposed to imply affirmative and reassuring measures, “brutality” immediately downplays any type of good there once was. Instantly, the objectives and duties of a police officer who is involved in cruelty, is then inverted and no longer suggests the safety and order that we, as a public, demand. He or she is then considered part of a widespread problem that is ongoing in many different areas of the world, and crime is not only what they’re intended to halt, but also what they are illegally entangled in.
In one incident, the murder of Sean Bell was a prime example of inappropriate force used on an innocent man. It occurred on November 25 of 2006 in Jamaica Queens, New York when Sean Bell and a few friends were leaving his bachelor party at a nearby strip club downtown. Five undercover officers then appeared at the location and let off 50 bullets, mortally wounding Bell and severely injuring his friends inside of their car. One may wonder what caused these officers to commit such a “crime”. Well they claimed they believed Bell and his associates were up to no good after a confrontation inside the club made the officers believe the group of men was armed and dangerous. Sadly, an eager and soon-to-be married Nicole Paultre-Bell was left in disarray during one of the most important events of her life, her wedding day. Let’s look at another occurrence to get a better feel of how some police forces decide to “secure the safety of the public”. One of the most popular cases was one that involved Rodney King in 1991 Los Angeles, California. “In 1991, a videotape circulated around the world of Rodney King being beaten by L.A.P.D. officers after they put an end to the 8-mile high speed chase. Once surrounded, King and his two friends were ordered to step out of the vehicle and lie face down on the ground. King refused to comply, but eventually got out of the car and resisted an arrest. Once King got physical with some of the officers, they shot him with a Taser gun to knock him to the ground. He was then beaten multiple times with a baton and kicked repeatedly.” (Criminal Justice Degrees Guide). This incident became a viral media sensation and developed into one of the most appalling police brutality incidents in history. When coupling the two words “police” and “brutality” together, it creates a greatly reversed negative connotation. While “police” is supposed to imply affirmative and reassuring measures, “brutality” immediately downplays any type of good there once was. Instantly, the objectives and duties of a police officer who is involved in cruelty, is then inverted and no longer suggests the safety and order that we, as a public, demand. He or she is then considered part of a widespread problem that is ongoing in many different areas of the world, and crime is not only what they’re intended to halt, but also what they are illegally entangled in.
Now
that we’ve gotten that out the way, let’s ask yet another question: “Is police
brutality even something worth worrying or causing a fuss about”? Does police
brutality exist and is it apparent? Yes is the answer to both of these
questions and there are so many situations, like those mentioned previously,
that prove its certainty. Usually in order for something to be a part of
reality, it tends to have both causes and effects that make it appear
reasonably imperative. The single fact that some instances of police cruelty
appears in the media as upheavals, is a very general way to know that it isn’t
just bent up, imaginative happenings that regular civilians create in their
heads as plots of vengeance for whatever reason. I also suppose something can
be considered an issue once action is taken against the matter. If it doesn’t
exist, why put time and much effort towards either promoting or in this case,
denouncing it? Examples of what I’m trying to convey could be groups of individuals
who come together for a single cause or purpose and stand for or against what
they believe to be as unjust or justified. There have been nationwide protests
and arguments against police brutality and unsurprisingly enough, always from
the recipients of the violent acts and rarely from their superiors. Going into
specifics of this matter, however, will have to take a rain check.
The
causes of police brutality are not entirely black and white simply because
everything starts with the individual. The captain of the precinct (hopefully)
doesn’t just entitle the officers to report for duty and beat anyone they feel
needs a good lesson. It’s always a personal act of judgment they make
independently and no one makes them do it. Sometimes, following an act of
cruelty, the officer will claim and believe his reasons were justified because
of “suspicion”, possible threats, or whatever sounds good to the judge or jury.
Then there’s the other group of ruthless individuals who do it just because. Sometimes
this act of un-needed violence is the product of concealed hate against the
civilian personally or the group they represent. Power is another factor that
causes police brutality. It is something that a lot of groups of higher
authority thrive off of and use to their advantage. But placed in the wrong
hands, that power can do far more harm than good. Some officers may feel as
though they are compelled to harm their “inferior” counterparts as a display of
their power and make their victims submissive to their rule.
I
guess the only thing left to wonder is, what is there to do about this reoccurring
issue and how does it weigh out on the infamous “halo-horn” scale? How do we,
as a community, go about solving this problem? This of course, is where an
individual gets to decide where he or she stands against this issue, since it
clearly is one.
Works Cited
"Police."
Def. 1. Dictionary.com. N.p., 2010.
Web. 17 Feb. 2012. <http://dictionary.reference.com/
browse/police>.
"Brutality."
Merriam-Webster. Merriam-Webster Incorporated, n.d. Web. 17 Feb. 2012.
<http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/brutality>.
"10
Worst Cases of Police Brutality in History." Criminal Justice Degrees Guide (July 2011): 1.
Criminal
Justice eCollection. Web. 17 Feb. 2012.
<http://www.criminaljusticedegreesguide.com/features/
10-worst-cases-of-police-brutality-in-history.html>.
Police
Brutality (Aug. 2001): 1. Answers.com. Web. 17 Feb. 2012. <http://www.answers.com/topic/
police-brutality>.
Wow you certainly explain some of the most horrific incidents that I didn't know much about before reading this. I liked the writing and found myself very eager to read more. You may want to check the spot about the "8 mile high speed chase" i think a comma would be useful somewhere in there to avoid confusion. Over-all a very well written engaging paper.
ReplyDeleteI'm really glad that you're bringing such an issue to light, and in such a well written manner. I really appreciate this essay.
ReplyDelete